Reality and desire: reproduction of the Tribune in the World of Elisa de la Nuez

The month that elapsed since 14-F and the lifting by the European Parliament of the immunity of MEPs Puigdemont, Ponsatí and Comín on March 9, has made it clear to what extent the supposed success of the Illa operation has remained a peep I want within the face of the cussed actuality that the Catalan independence motion is just not a dependable ally. There has not been the slightest try and agree on a supposedly progressive tripartite (contemplating a reactionary nationalist social gathering like ERC progressive continues to be one other pious want) within the face of the clear curiosity of the separatist events to proceed taking on the positions, the budgets and the equipment of energy in Catalonia, with or with out independence in sight, that that is starting to not be so important. Or quite, it’s the excellent excuse to systematically exclude from the Authorities and the perks that it entails in every single place and in Catalonia, in all probability greater than in any a part of Spain, half the inhabitants. Within the intolerant democracy through which Catalonia is changing into visibly political minorities (regardless that they’re nearly all of the inhabitants) don’t depend to the extent that the system of institutional checks and balances that ought to defend them in opposition to excesses of the bulk. However, the offended reactions of the independence motion to the lifting of the immunity of the escaped MEPs (do not forget that the PSOE within the European Parliament voted in favor of the rebellion whereas its authorities companion, Podemos, voted in opposition to) doesn’t bode effectively. for the soundness of the coalition authorities.

The truth is that the pragmatism and sense of the State of Esquerra Republicana (so praised by the Authorities in change for its help) has given technique to the standard wrestle for the assets of the Generalitat and for primacy within the pro-independence world, with a upward public sale by way of rhetoric and threats of rupture, not with the constitutional order (which is what the independence program consists of) however with the coalition authorities. Which, by the way in which, was completely predictable for any dispassionate viewer. Thus, the one agreements that appear potential are these reached by the pro-independence events with the help of this discovering, which is the CUP, a celebration whose voters don’t respect any inconsistency in being, on the similar time, essentially the most anti-system and people of upper revenue from the Catalan parliamentary arch. After all when the revolution It’s performed by the wealthiest lessons in opposition to essentially the most deprived, all the things is profoundly incoherent. Therefore, the Catalan Authorities finds it so troublesome to manage avenue issues or mobilizations in favor of figures like Pablo Hasel when he encourages them himself, at the very least spiritually. , it is the suck and puff factor.

Neither the trail that the PSC advocated with a exceptional voluntarism (or goodness, if you happen to want) had an extended technique to go. The return to a supposed Arcadia previous to 2017 (erasing this fateful date from the political map) through which Catalanism reigned peacefully in Catalan society and the extremes have been simply that, extremes, it’s merely not potential. Now we all know that the consensus constructed on the silence of nearly all of Catalans was by no means such. In any case, it has been blown up and the dynamitors have been the nationalists: it doesn’t appear that there’s a lot to rescue from the Catalan oasis, shattered by its personal creators. Non-nationalist residents are effectively conscious that the Authorities doesn’t take it into consideration, in the very best of circumstances, or tries to silence them by way of social and political coercion at worst. Every thing is beneath query: from the alleged success of the linguistic immersion to the hegemony of the media managed by the Generalitat via the actions of the Mossos within the recurring episodes of avenue violence in Barcelona. And for good causes.

On this scenario, the trail of dialogue, the magic phrase that entails the invitation to return to the the state of nationalist political dominance however with out surprises and with the approval of the dominated, it appears to me that it has little path, past gesticulation and tacticism. Actually, whereas the independentistas negotiate amongst themselves in Catalonia with out giving any choice to essentially the most voted social gathering, the PSC, Congress approves by a majority of 187 deputies an ERC movement through which the Authorities is urged to satisfy, instantly, on the bilateral dialogue and negotiation desk with the Authorities that’s constituted to advance “within the decision of the political battle between Catalonia and the Spanish State.” The PSOE has voted in favor, though from the social gathering they guarantee that the negotiation can be performed throughout the Structure and the legal guidelines. Tough to sq. the circle when one social gathering needs to barter the constitutional and authorized framework.

ERC’s proposal is identical as at all times: the popularity of the correct to self-determination and now additionally amnesty for these it considers “political prisoners.” The one novelty is that its calls for are actually supposed to be the results of concessions made at a dialogue desk and little else. The query of a dialogue between two topics (Catalonia and the Spanish State) that aren’t comparable, provided that one is an autonomous neighborhood of the opposite or through which the thing of the negotiation is the rule of regulation, the Structure and the personal nationwide sovereignty (which in the present day and except the Structure is modified resides in the entire of the Spanish folks) doesn’t appear to alarm the Authorities an excessive amount of. To not point out these whom nobody represents anymore, neither the Generalitat nor the Authorities, and who might really feel forgotten: the non-nationalist residents of Catalonia. In conclusion, within the framework of a democratic rule of regulation, this negotiating desk has a really troublesome match, since these points can solely be addressed throughout the framework of a constitutional reform for which the negotiators should not have a adequate majority. That the negotiating desk meets to conclude {that a} constitutional reform is critical to accommodate the independence claims (assuming that almost all will is to finish nationwide sovereignty and territorial unity, which is lots to imagine) I don’t assume it’s the thought of its promoters.

To additional muddy the scenario, the coalition authorities has two souls in a matter as essential because the very existence of a rule of regulation and a full democracy in Spain. When United We will vote in opposition to (together with the European excessive proper, by the way in which) to carry the immunity of the escaped pro-independence deputies, we can’t overlook that they’re assuming the discourse or the story, if you happen to want, that Spain is just not a democracy comparable with others. European nations and that it doesn’t have a rule of regulation worthy of the title. Which, then again, the nonetheless vice chairman Pablo Iglesias has mentioned publicly, so it’s not a shock both.

With these wickers, advancing within the answer of the Catalan battle doesn’t appear potential. The conflict of identities, achieved via a nationalist effort to make Catalan id incompatible with Spanish id and to make all the things Spanish an exterior enemy to defeat, with the resultant fracture of Catalan society, is just not simple to restore. The loneliness of non-nationalist voters because of the failure of the establishments, beginning with that of the State, which ought to defend them is flagrant. The gradual financial, social and, above all, ethical decline in Catalonia doesn’t appear, in the present day, simply reversible. But when we will draw one lesson from this catastrophe, it’s that ignoring that the legal guidelines in Catalonia are non-obligatory (at the very least for nationalist rulers) is just not a good suggestion. Wanting the opposite method when the rule of regulation is violated in an autonomy doesn’t appear to be an excellent thought. The outcomes are in sight. Maybe we may begin by demanding that everybody, rulers and dominated, nationalists and non-nationalists, strictly respect the foundations of the sport.

Maybe the one ray of optimism is the one which comes from the European establishments. That the independence motion has not managed to impose its story besides among the many extremely and Eurosceptic deputies, regardless of what number of they’re, continues to be superb information. In that sense, we now have to grasp and make it understood that what we now have in Catalonia, on a small scale, is identical intolerant democracy mannequin that worries the EU a lot in different Member States akin to Poland and Hungary. That the EU understands that it is usually essential to combat illiberalism on the regional degree appears to me to be a main situation. And forestall this mannequin from being exported to different areas of Spain as effectively. On this process we should use all of the instruments that the rule of regulation makes out there to us.

You May Also Like

About the Author: admin

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *